|
-
G u i t a r T i p s -
So your fingers won't cooperate, eh?
Hi Steve,
I just bought my first guitar, electric. My problem is: When I press down on a string with my middle finger I can't keep it from touching the string below it. So playing a chord is next to impossible. It happens less but still happens with the first and third fingers as well. My fingers are pretty average. Is there anything made to cover the finger tips?
Thanks,
Bruce
It's hard to be completely sure about why you're having said problem w/o
seeing your fingers make the moves, but I can take a good educated guess.
Assuming your fingers aren't extremely large or bulbous (you said
"average"), the problem is likely one of finger angling. Most likely, your
wrist is not bent enough, and your palm may be riding too high behind the
guitar neck. More wrist bend, and a lower point of contact BEHIND the neck
should help you to curve your fingers more. Also, more bend in your 3rd
finger knuckle (nearest the fingertip) gives you more finger curve. More
curve gets the fingertip away from the string below the one you're pressing
on.
Most guitar chord fingerings are built from "compromise" angles. That is,
placement of each finger has to be such that it can produce its note or
notes without preventing other fingers from assuming a useful angle. A good
example is everyone's first D chord:
1|---------|--------1-|----------|--
2|---------|-----------|-------3-|--
3|---------|--------2-|----------|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|--0
5|---------|-----------|----------|--X
6|---------|-----------|----------|--X
frets: 1 2
3
Fingers 1 and 2 line up vertically along the 2nd fret. A bent wrist helps
to accomplish that line-up. But the 3rd finger (placed on the 2nd string)
has to assume a sideways slant in order to reach the 3rd fret WITHOUT touching the first string. Of course, it takes work to get the 3rd finger
to angle correctly, because the position of both the wrist and fingers 1 and
2 don't faciliate the 3rd finger position. You get used to it, THEN (much
later) it begins to feel natural.
The whole range of finger position challenges are solved by patiently
practicisng the best angles that your fingers can assume. There's no device
to buy-- you just work it out. For more general advice on this subject, see the "Spread & Curve" entry at the bottom of this page.
Basic Finger-Style Technique
I happen to teach a "3-fingers + thumb"
approach. Many players use "2-fingers + thumb."
The cardinal rule: Divide up the work between the
individual digits, so that no one finger is doing too much of the
plucking. You may not always need all 3 fingers to play a part,
but the thumb is nearly always in use.
Like the "home keys" in typing, there
is a general assignment of strings to fingers, as below:
"Bass" strings: 6E played by thumb (noted
as "P" for Spanish "pulgar")
5A
"
4D
"
"Treble" strings: 3G played by index finger (noted
as "I" for "indecio")
2B
played by middle finger ("M" for "medio")
1E
played by ring finger ("A" for "andular")
The above assignment works most of the time, however,
fingers may sometimes cluster on the "bass" strings for
particular patterns. This is especially true if there is a general
logic to the finger placement. For example, a picking pattern may
not involve the 1st string at all. If so, then the fingers may be
"reassigned" to pluck lower strings.
The player should usually avoid using the middle
finger (M) on the 1st string, or the index finger (I) on the 2nd
string when adopting the "3 finger" approach. Although
there are "specialty" moves that break the rules, for
development purposes, we assign one finger to each treble string,
and the thumb plays the bass strings.
Strums may be produced by a downward stroke of a
finger nail across the strings (sharper, brighter tone), or by a
downward stroke of the thumb, followed by an upward finger stroke
(rounded, mellow tone). Wearers of thumb and finger picks will have
to use the latter technique.
Here's a simple pattern to get you started. All
notes are valued as 8th notes. Try using an Am chord:
Count: 1 + 2 + 3 + 4
+ (8th notes)
String: 5 2 4 3 5
2 4 3 play strings 5 & 1 together
on beat 1
1
Some moveable "small form" chord
fingerings:
Some of these (examples 2 and 6) look very much like
the basic open position chords from which they are all derived.
The rest of the fingerings are modified so they can move up and
down the strings, providing a new major or minor small (i.e.: 3
note) chord at every location along the 1st, 2nd and 3rd strings. The examples below make use of open bass strings to broaden
the overall sound. As you study these diagrams, make careful
note of the fret positions described below the guitar neck diagram.
ex. 1: D
(root on 3rd string)
1|-----1--|-----------|----------|--
2|---------|-----------|-------4-|--
3|---------|-----------|------3--|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|--0
5|---------|-----------|----------|--0orX
6|---------|-----------|----------|--X
frets: 5
6
7
ex.2: E
(root on 2nd string)
1|---------|--------1-|----------|--
2|---------|-----------|-------3-|--
3|---------|--------2-|----------|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|--X
5|---------|-----------|----------|--X
6|---------|-----------|----------|--0
frets: 3
4
5
ex. 3: A (root
on 1st string)
1|---------|--------1-|----------|--
2|---------|--------1-|----------|--
3|---------|-----------|------2--|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|--X
5|---------|-----------|----------|--0
6|---------|-----------|----------|--0orX
frets: 4
5 6
ex. 4: Dm (root
on 3rd string)
1|------1-|-----------|----------|--
2|---------|--------2-|----------|--
3|---------|-----------|-------3-|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|--O
5|---------|-----------|----------|--O or X
6|---------|-----------|----------|--X
frets: 5
6
7
ex. 5: Am (root
on 1st string)
1|-------1-|-----------|----------|--
2|-------1-|-----------|----------|--
3|-------1-|-----------|----------|--
4|----------|-----------|--------3|--
5|----------|-----------|----------|-- O
6|----------|-----------|----------|-- O or X
frets: 5 6
7
ex .6: Em (root
on 2nd string)
1|------1-|-----------|----------|--
2|---------|-----------|-------3-|--
3|---------|--------2-|----------|--
4|---------|-----------|----------|-- X
5|---------|-----------|----------|-- X
6|---------|-----------|----------|-- O
frets: 3
4
5
These forms are good starting points for inventing
riffs. They are often used with rhythmic arpeggio pattern-picking
to create 2nd guitar parts over the basic strummed chords. Any
Beatles record has several good examples of small chord use, but
they are used to great effect in all western music genres. There
are many other small forms that suggest other chords, but these
are the six basic formations for the upper 3 strings, and they give
you three locations along the fretboard for each major and each
minor chord. They are slide-able and bend-able. They
can be broken down into 2-note combinations, for which the fingerings
can be further modified. Practice them until each fingering
is memorized. You should be able to name each small-form chord
at each fretboard location.
"I Ain't Got Time to Practice."
Maybe you really don't have any free time....but
maybe you have a few minutes of down time here and there that could
be spent doing something repetitive that can train the fingers,
at least, if not the mind. It's hard to be a creative genius
if you only play 10-15 minutes a day. But, while you anticipate
having more creative time to explore your instrument, you can keep
yourself more ready to create by playing through simple, well-memorized
finger exercises that improve or at least maintain your dexterity.
Here are a few areas that the beginner or intermediate
guitarist can work on, almost mindlessly:
1] alternate picking exercises: examine how
well you hold the pick; go for a steady, flowing pick attack
and don't worry about speed-- only timing and clarity. I know guitarists
who watch sports on TV with guitar in hand, and they do string-skipping
alternate picking exercises while the ads are on.
2] learn a new chord: try the back pages
of your chord book. Work on one fingering repeatedly, until thoroughly
memorized. You cain't use it if it ain't memorized.
3] learn a new scale pattern: remember the
one-fret-per-finger rule as you do this. Repeat, repeat, repeat....
4] work out a new riff: related to #3 above
5] take care of any "remedial" knowledge:
Have you never memorized the notes on the open strings? Can you
close your eyes and slide a finger from the 5th to the 7th fret?
Accurately? Do you know on which string the "root" bass
note of each common chord is located? Can you locate octave
notes on different strings? It's like cramming for a one-question
test.... you can handle that.
Of course, doing all of the above with a mindful
attitude, paying close attention to detail is absolutely the best
way to go. But if it's a question of chipping away at the challenges
OR doing nothing about them, I'd say keep at it any way you can
manage, and you will maintain a higher level of skill
which can be brought to bear whenever the pace of life slacks off.
D o n ' t C o p y g u i t a r i s t
s o n T V
Rock stars posing... yeah-- they look cool.
But, remember, that's the only real goal of those videos--
to look good whilst pretending to play. So they wear
the guitar well below the navel, and strum from the elbow-- it's
nicely visual, but it impairs your reach and your ability to control
the dynamics (differing volume levels) of your playing. Of
course, if you're spending thousands of $$$ on a video, and your
music has no dynamics anyway, then the rock star posturing may be
the way to go.
But if you are trying to improve your strumming
coordination, or your chord formations, then wearing the guitar
at a low altitude may hinder your progress, because you have to
bend your wrist too severely to reach the neck, and that will often
compromise your leverage. Also, if you're trying for the advanced
strum patterns heard in funk/soul jazz-rock whatever, you need to
control your strums from the wrist muscles, NOT from the
elbow, as is so often seen on TV. That will be difficult to
do if you wear the guitar too low-- you can't approach the
strings with the best angle if you're wearing the guitar on your
hip. But raise that guitar up a bit, and you'll be able to
reach all the strings more easily with both hands.
Listen to recordings by James Brown (Jimmy
Nolen on guitar-- he practically invented funk strumming),
Booker T & the MGs (w/Steve Cropper, whose touch and timing
are a joy to hear), and if you dig around, you can find recordings
that include relative newcomer Avi Bortnick. When I saw him
with John Scofield (check the CD "Up All Night")
his rhythm playing was so exquisitely funky that he repeatedly stole
my attention away from Sco's amazing guitar solos, and that ain't
easy to do. These are 3 players who really help to set the
standard for world-class rhythm guitar playing. If you want
to sound that good, you have to adopt a playing stance that allows
to you fully develop those all-important wrist muscles.
Hey, players-- if you have anything to add
to the discussions above or below, please e-mail me, and I may include
your opinions in a future installment.
S P A C E A N D T I M
E
Take a short musical phrase, just a few notes, and
work that phrase into several different "shapes" by changing
the time value of some of the notes and varying where the accented
beats fall. Same notes, same sequence. It's OK to repeat
some of the notes, but hang on to the same notes, same sequence.
If you quickly fall into playing exact repetitions,
try a considerable variation in your chosen tempo (i.e.: much slower
or much faster than where you started). The idea is
to create more than a few variations. Of course, proceed into
a real solo, with new note choices eventually. By manipulating
timing and dynamics, you achieve a fresher approach to soloing than
you would by merely spewing out lots of new note combinations. Most
of us would agree that emotional content is greatly enhanced by
effectively timing the delivery of notes and phrases. So if
you spend some conscious practice time re-working the timing and
dynamic aspects of your melodies and riffs, you improve your intuitive
sense of how to improvise with a strong command of dynamics
and timing. A true cliche: the silences around your
notes are just as important as the notes themselves. You can say
it in 20 notes or 2000 notes, but at least you'll appreciate the
difference between a dense and a spacious approach.
Hey You!
What Are You Listening To?
I know some serious guitar pickers who are working hard at their
craft. You hear 'em, and you know that they put in a lot of time
improving their playing. Unfortunately, many of them sound
like a complete copy of their hero(es) 'cuz that's all they listen
to. You know: blues players who cop all of Stevie Ray Vaughn's
licks, a jazz player who borrows too much of Pat Metheny's tone
and compositional sense, or worse, a folk strummer who's trying
to sound just like Woody Gutherie. Great chops, no originality.
You could argue that the market rewards those who render the
same old stuff, but the greats didn't get that way by copying another's
act. Could be that what we all need to do is search outside
of our own chosen area of musical expertise, and listen to someone
making good music in a style that's not close to our own-- perhaps
even someone who plays a different instrument!
The usual recommendation is to listen to horn players for a greater
sense of melody-- after all, you don't play chords on a sax (though
horn sections are a great source of inspiration when you're
trying to find a sequence of small-form chords that will work together
melodically). I've learned a few moves from listening to piano
players. I never can get all the notes that they are able
to hit, but I have picked up on that layered sound that two-handed
keyboard players achieve combining bass and treble notes, and taken
that approach into my finger-style playing. Imagine a blues
player learning from the melody of a contemporary folk song. Imagine
a metal player grooving better after listening to some Latin styles.
Imagine a folk finger-picker getting new harmony ideas from
listening to classic jazz. Imagine (American) country guitarists
twisting some African guitar licks around until they fit into their
well-rehearsed style. Imagine....

S p r e a d & C u r v e!
Yeah,
you know all about it....And it is kind of remedial, but
even the pros flub some notes 'cuz our fingers just land too flat
or too far from the fret once in awhile. It's a problem esp. with
chord fingerings-- it's that B bass note on the 5th string you don't
get when you finger an open G chord, or worse, the open G 3rd string
that doesn't ring in the middle of your open C chord-- brings everybody
at the campfire down ;-)
Well,
our fingers bend in 3 places-- remember that 3rd knuckle right below
the fingertip. Curve it more, and you usually lessen the surface
area that a given finger covers on the fretboard. That makes it
less likely that you'll bump into strings in an unwanted fashion.
Also,
notice if your fingers really stretch out to just-behind-the-fret
(esp. the 4th finger). Play a few scales, slowly fer crissakes.
If you're landing 1/4" to 1/8" away from the intended
fret, your notes are gonna buzz pretty often and you'll probably
lose sustain. Try to do more finger-reaching than hand shifting
if you're operating within a 4-fret span. It might really matter
if you're hittin' what you intend to hit-- it ain't like old times
when the novelty of high-volume guitar antics sort of made up for
a bad hit/miss ratio. Nowadays even your mother can tell if you're
playing sloppily. So don't let the dear lady down,
esp. if she bought you your first guitar.
Oh yeah, and change your %$#*! strings once in a while!
....and
wash yer hands between eating ribs and pickin' up your sufferin'
guitar. |